Yes because they helped a bunch of people
The Adams ale was poisoned.everybody knew except her , Emily. It was a common ritual in order to get into the crimson skulls club where she had to make a decision. Was master lying or telling the truth about the ale . It was clear to everyone when he slyly spoke “the water is not poisoned”. I’m that moment she was dauntless but crumbling on the inside die being the cynosure.she was being judged and she knew it .everybody knew she was callow when she said “your lying “ .the rest is history
