1answer.
Ask question
Login Signup
Ask question
All categories
  • English
  • Mathematics
  • Social Studies
  • Business
  • History
  • Health
  • Geography
  • Biology
  • Physics
  • Chemistry
  • Computers and Technology
  • Arts
  • World Languages
  • Spanish
  • French
  • German
  • Advanced Placement (AP)
  • SAT
  • Medicine
  • Law
  • Engineering
aleksandrvk [35]
3 years ago
7

The plaintiff, a resident of State A, was visiting the home of the defendant, who resides in State B. As the plaintiff was leavi

ng the house, she fell through a rotted plank in the front steps and broke her ankle. The plaintiff underwent several surgeries and extensive rehabilitation. She brought suit in federal district court, alleging that the defendant negligently maintained her premises and asking for relief in the amount of $150,000. The defendant filed a counterclaim alleging that the plaintiff owes her $5,000 as payment for web design work that the defendant completed for the plaintiff. If the plaintiff filed a motion to dismiss the defendant’s counterclaim for lack of jurisdiction, will the plaintiff succeed?
A. No, because the parties maintain complete diversity.
B. No, because the federal district court may exercise supplemental jurisdiction over counterclaims.
C. Yes, because the defendant’s counterclaim does not meet the amount-in-controversy requirement for diversity jurisdiction.
D. Yes, because the federal district court may only exercise supplemental jurisdiction when the action includes compulsory counterclaims.
Social Studies
1 answer:
ad-work [718]3 years ago
4 0

Answer:

Hi! The answer would be option C. Yes, because the defendant’s counterclaim does not meet the amount-in-controversy requirement for diversity jurisdiction.

Explanation:

A federal court may assert supplemental jurisdiction over a counterclaim that does not satisfy the jurisdictional amount when the counterclaim is compulsory. However, a permissive counterclaim does not qualify for supplemental jurisdiction and therefore must satisfy the jurisdictional amount and the rule of complete diversity. Here, the defendant's claim that the plaintiff owes her money does not arise out of the same transaction and occurrence as the plaintiff's injuries. Therefore, the defendant's counterclaim is permissive and must meet the amount-in-controversy requirement for diversity jurisdiction. Answer choice A is incorrect. Although the parties must maintain complete diversity, a permissive counterclaim must also meet the amount-in-controversy requirement. Answer choice B is incorrect. Although the federal district court may exercise supplemental jurisdiction over counterclaims, a permissive counterclaim needs to meet the requirements for federal subject-matter jurisdiction (either diversity or federal question). Answer choice D is incorrect. While it is true that the defendant's counterclaim is not compulsory, it would be possible for the federal court to assert diversity jurisdiction had the defendant met the amount-in-controversy requirement. Therefore, D is not the best answer choice.

You might be interested in
Which American industry first used machines to do work previously done by hand?
inessss [21]
American industry first used machines to do work previously done by hand is letter D which is cotton farming. Cotton has been in American industry since 1500's documented from sightings by the Coronado expedition 1540-42. White Gold is the appropriate term for cotton, <span>the natural fiber which continues to play an important role in the United States economy.</span>  

7 0
2 years ago
The executive committee needs to decide whether to form a C Corp or an S Corp. You suggest an S Corp. because of the tax incenti
allochka39001 [22]

Answer:

the answer is false.

There are many differences between s corps and c corps .But in the comparison C corp is better than S corp in these case of decision

Explanation:

4 0
3 years ago
In order to lessen the risk of accidents caused by careless driving and jaywalking at a busy intersection, the town of Polvin ha
omeli [17]

Answer:The speed limit for the stretch of road on which the intersection is found.

Explanation:

3 0
2 years ago
In the country of Lesotho a king is the head of state but a prime minister holds governmental power. This is an example of what
dimulka [17.4K]
The answer to the question is B
8 0
3 years ago
Read 2 more answers
IWhy would you spend extra money on high-quality products? because you cannot trust no-name brand products because you should al
juin [17]

Answer: because these could save you money later by lasting longer

Explanation:

When making purchases on products, it's always advisable to buy high quality products. Choosing quality over price helps in the elimination of waste, and improvement of efficienct.

As consumers, when we buy high quality products, they tend to last longer than buying products that are of low quality even though those ones may be cheaper.

Therefore, spending extra money on high-quality products can save one money later by lasting longer.

8 0
3 years ago
Other questions:
  • In what way was Harriet Beecher Stowe's book Uncle Tom's Cabin so important to the abolition movement? A.It exposed the evils an
    13·2 answers
  • For younger drivers, which of the following is NOT considered a risk
    7·2 answers
  • The government answers all three economic questions in a
    5·1 answer
  • A social research methods class wants to study smoking. First, the professor asks how many people in the class are smokers. Two
    8·1 answer
  • Discribe any six risky situations young people are frequently exposed to​
    7·2 answers
  • What kinds of problems may occur in the absence of empathy and cooperation? Write with example​
    13·1 answer
  • How did the thirteen colonies benefit by working together?
    7·1 answer
  • Using complete sentences explain the differences between a command economy and a market economy. What type of economic system is
    5·1 answer
  • In the 1940s, researchers Clark and Clark (1947) gave African American children a choice between Black dolls and White dolls. Re
    15·1 answer
  • Communicating to the client the potential risks and benefits of therapy, confidentiality and its limits, and the expected length
    11·1 answer
Add answer
Login
Not registered? Fast signup
Signup
Login Signup
Ask question!