The Giver Questions-There are two instances of rule-breaking in this chapter. Consider each one. Do you feel the punishment was
justified? Explain your reasoning. Why were the rules “very hard to change”?
What is so important about the “ceremony of twelve”?
What kind of job do you think Jonas will get? Explain your reasoning.
If some older people in your community were to observe you, what job do you think they would give you and why?
Punishment was never justified, EVER!!! rules were rules, the elders would rarely budge jonas might recieve a selective i would be a birthmother or a recreational director
