Question

Read the claim.

Answer 1

From the given choices, all three seem to agree with the counterclaim. Since, we are asked to address the counterclaim, it is then evident that we should at the very least be against or have an opposite opinion that what is presented in the counterclaim. The best answer to this item should be the first choice. 

Answer 2

The Economic Policy Institute shows that raising the minimum wage will grow the economy so that actually there will be one hundred thousand new jobs.

This is the best counterclaim. It shows, with facts, how raising the minimum wage will create new jobs. This is best because it doesn't include personal opinion or any vague statements that cannot be proven. Option B states that it is also factual; however, it's statement supports the counterclaim rather than eliminates it. In an essay the purpose of addressing the counterclaim is to show why arguments against your topic are incorrect. Option C is too informal to even be considered. Option D does not really show whether or not the minimum wage change is positive or negative.