1answer.
Ask question
Login Signup
Ask question
All categories
  • English
  • Mathematics
  • Social Studies
  • Business
  • History
  • Health
  • Geography
  • Biology
  • Physics
  • Chemistry
  • Computers and Technology
  • Arts
  • World Languages
  • Spanish
  • French
  • German
  • Advanced Placement (AP)
  • SAT
  • Medicine
  • Law
  • Engineering
Artemon [7]
3 years ago
6

An argumentative essay that responds to Lifeboat Ethics by Garret Hardin.

English
1 answer:
Anastaziya [24]3 years ago
7 0

Answer:

Garrett Hardin argues for a very harsh thesis: we simply should not provide aid to people in poor countries. His argument is consequentialist: he claims that the net result of doing so would be negative -- would in fact be courting large-scale disaster. One of the things that we will notice about Hardin's essay, however, is that whether he is right or wrong, he paints with a very broad brush. This makes it a good essay for the honing of your philosophical skills; you should notice that there are many places where the reasoning procees with less than total care.

Hardin begins with metaphors. He points out that while the metaphor of earth as a grand spaceship has a certain popularity (or did 23 years ago) it is a flawed metaphor…show more content…

Aren't we irresponsible if we don't plan ahead for possible emergencies by leaving ourselves some excess capacity? (Recall that in this metaphor, capacity includes things like supplies.) It should be obvious that this is a dubious metaphor. To begin with (and this will come up again) not all countries are either rich or poor. Furthermore, it is not as clear as Hardin assumes that we lack the resources to save everyone. And the argument from the safety factor may seem dubious. Couldn't we help some people -- even if we select them in a fairly arbitrary way? Leave the safety factor aside. Presumably it is true that we should not give all our "excess" resources away; not planning for emergencies is irresponsible. The main reply that Hardin would make to our doubts is this: even if we have enough resources to help everyone in the short run, we don't have nearly enough to do so in the long run. Why not? Because of the difference in rates of population growth between rich and poor nations. Suppose that in 1974, the U.S. had decided to share its wealth with a group of countries such as Columbia, Venezuala and Pakistan. Suppose that the combined population of the poor countries equaled the total (1974) populationof the U.S.: about 210 million. The populaiton in the U.S. increass at a rate of about .8% per year; the population of those countries increases at a rate of about 3.3% per year. By 2061 -- 87 years later -- the population of the U.S. would

Show More

Related

Justice vs. Reality in "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor" by Garrett Hardin

534 Words  | 3 Pages

The essay titled "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor" by Garrett Hardin, was very interesting. The first part of the essay used a metaphor of the rich people of the earth in a lifeboat and the poor people in the sea drowning. The rich people could only allow a few people in and if they let, too many people in they will sink the boat and all die. The best thing for the rich people to do is not to let anyone in so they will have adequate supplies and space for them to survive. Later

Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor - Garrett Hardin What Should A Billionaire Give-and What Should You? - Peter Singer

3380 Words  | 14 Pages

Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor - Garrett Hardin What Should A Billionaire Give-and What Should You? - Peter Singer One of the most important issues facing the world today is the issue of the poor. There are many things that can be done about this issue, however much of the world is torn between wanting to help and not knowing how to go about it. This is the issue that is presented in the two essays - Garrett Hardin’s “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor,” and

Read More

The Effective Concept of Lifeboat Ethics Essay

1482 Words  | 6 Pages

Lifeboat Ethics is a metaphor for the process of wealth and resource distribution as described by ecologist Garrett Hardin. In 1974, he published an article called, “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor,” that outlines his reasons that the wealthy nations of the world should not be wholly responsible for supporting the needs of the poor. Donald Kennedy and William Clark both wrote articles in regard to the concept of lifeboat ethics and the tragedy of the commons. In the article, Hardin

Lifeboat Ethics By Garret Hardin And A Modest Proposal By Jonathan Swift

935 Words  | 4 Pages

Lifeboat ethics by Garret Hardin and a modest proposal by Jonathan Swift Garrett Hardin in 'Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against the Poor Garrett Hardin describes about how the well-off states are in the lifeboat and the deprived states are swimming in the sea. He also tells about how the US facilitates other states. Hardin thinks that if the administration remains serving other states and letting citizens in then America will also sink. We must encourage them if we desire to save at least part of

Explanation:

You might be interested in
Which sentence in the passage reveals the author’s point of view? Recycling consists of the processes of collecting, processing,
max2010maxim [7]
“If everyone participated in recycling, our planet just might be greener for our next generation
4 0
3 years ago
Read 2 more answers
WILL MARK BRAINLIEST!!!
kari74 [83]
Fallacies are common errors in reasoning is not true
8 0
2 years ago
Read 2 more answers
Which sentence best expresses the central argument of President Barack Obama’s back to school speech
Sauron [17]

Answer: A) It is your responsibility to yourself and to the United States to work hard in school

Explanation: i just took the test and got a 100% !! hope you pass

3 0
3 years ago
Help here ASAP TY 11 points
WARRIOR [948]
Is there a reading to this?
7 0
3 years ago
Read 2 more answers
I need a 1 1/2 pages summary about the book “Every Soul A Star”. It cannot be from other sources. It has to be written in your o
Rzqust [24]
Hey There!!!!


The answer is >

This is a summary of the lives of three different teenagers who meet during a rare and total solar eclipse

Ally is a bright, self-confident, homeschooled young teen who loves her life just as it is. She and her brother Kenny help their parents run their beautiful and remote Moon Shadow campground site in the “Middle of Nowhere, USA,” where Ally knows “every tree and every rock and which foxes are friendly and which aren’t.” In a pouch around her neck, Ally (whose real name happens to be Alpha) wears a meteorite that was given to her by her beloved grandfather --- she loves the sky just as much as he did. Ally, Kenny, and their parents have spent the past decade readying themselves for the onslaught of thousands of visitors who will descend on their campground in a few days when Moon Shadow will be the very best place on Earth to view a once-in-a-century total solar eclipse.

Bree --- beautiful, popular and destined to be a model --- has always suspected she was switched at birth. Bree’s parents are astrophysicists; her 11-year-old sister Melanie happily turns cartwheels in public, is unconcerned about being cool, and actually <em>likes</em> watching PBS documentaries. In Bree’s estimate, in a family that is proudly vanilla, she is “peanut butter rocky road with multicolored sprinkles, hot fudge, and a cherry on top.” Except, of course, she would never actually eat something like that --- it would just go straight to her thighs.

Lonely, chubby Jack has failed Mr. Silver’s science class. Instead of making him take a science class over the summer, Mr. Silver offers him the chance to be his assistant on an eclipse-viewing trip to the Moon Shadow campground. Jack has no idea why he was picked --- his strengths lie in art and his ability to fly during lucid dreaming (a trick he picked up from one of his many stepfathers); he is certainly no avid camper and doesn’t know a thing about astronomy. But anything has to be better than taking a science class during the summer, and so he reluctantly signs on for the eclipse tour.

Ally and Bree are stunned to learn that their families are essentially going to be trading places: Ally’s family is moving to “civilization” to expose the (very reluctant) kids to new cultural experiences, and Bree’s family will be taking their place in running the campground so that Bree’s parents can conduct their astrophysical research from Moon Shadow. The horrified girls decide to work together to foil their parents’ plans while preparing for the eclipse and the onslaught of visitors it will bring to the campground.

The story is told in turns by Ally, Bree, and Jack; to the author’s credit, each character’s voice rings true and is equally compelling. Minor characters, especially Ally’s kid brother Kenny, Bree’s sister Melanie, and Ally’s childhood friend (and possible crush) Ryan are also interesting and believable, almost worthy of books of their own. The adults and their actions provide a plot and backdrop to the story without intruding too much into the daily lives of the teens.

The sky --- the stars, the sun, the moon, the eclipse --- really forms another, absolutely fascinating character in the story. It is impossible not to come away with a greater appreciation of eclipses and astronomy in general after reading this book. Wendy Mass is able to distill scientific knowledge for the lay reader in a way that enhances the narrative without slowing down the pace of the novel. A narrative thread running through the story points to the great contributions that amateur astronomers (yes, even kids!) can make to the advancement of the science.

4 0
3 years ago
Other questions:
  • Hawthorne states that Brown's wife is "aptly named," Faith (ie., her name fits her personality). After reading the story, do you
    15·1 answer
  • Freewriting is a tool used to _____.
    9·2 answers
  • Why does holden feel he must protect jane?
    15·1 answer
  • Select the response that best answers the question. If the statement is true, select "True"; if it is false, select "False." In
    9·1 answer
  • Please help me again (sorry for asking so much)!
    5·1 answer
  • If I .............you, I would never angry with my friends.(was,were)​
    7·2 answers
  • Hiii you can help me pliss :(
    13·2 answers
  • Which best captures the image conveyed by the phrases "pressing into her soul" and "conditions which crowded her in"? an open ai
    12·2 answers
  • What were transcendentalists values
    7·2 answers
  • Question 1
    15·2 answers
Add answer
Login
Not registered? Fast signup
Signup
Login Signup
Ask question!