She will use more than 1/4 cup of sugar to make 1.5 batches of muffins. If one batch of muffins requires 1/4 cup of sugar, you can think of the amount of sugar needed being 1/4 cup per batch. That being said multiply 1.5 batches by 1/4 cup per batch to find cups of sugar. (1.5 batches)x((1/4 cups)/(1 batch))=0.375 cups of sugar.
You can also think of it as if one batch takes 1/4 cup of sugar, half of a batch would take 1/8 cup of sugar. Since 1.5 batches is just 1 batch+1/2 batch, you can say the amount of sugar needed is 1/4 cup+1/8 cup which equals 3/8 cup sugar.