Answer:
The best answer from the options, for the question: What is one way in which Black argues against the majority opinion, would be, A: He argues that the court has not protected teachers´ and students´ rights for 50 years.
Explanation:
Justice Hugo L. Black was one of the Supreme Court members who decided to dissent against the majority decision that was made on the case <em>Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District</em>, in 1969. Although the final decision was to uphold the initial lawsuit against the Des Moines school district, for having suspended the 7 students who decided to go against the school´s order not to wear the black armbands in protest for the death of Americans in Vietnam, Justice Black decided to dissent the decision. The final vote was 7 against 2 dissenting Justices, one of which, was Black.
Among the many reasons given by Justice Black for dissenting on the final decision was not only that he believed people did not have the right to say whatever they wanted, wherever and whenever they wanted it, as the First and Fourtheenth Amendment established, but he also believed that even if the majority were to go and accept something as true, or constitutional, like upholding that any person has the right to do whatever they want, because they are protected by these amendments, he believes that it is also within a School District´s rights to enforce regulations and orders that, under the State´s legislature, ensure the correct functioning of the school, and that it is not in the Court´s reach to breach that right, or interfere on the way that school districts, under a State´s legislature, govern and rule their pupils and their teachers. This is why the best answer from the options is A.
