Four weeks after Jonas stops taking his pills, an unscheduled holiday is declared in the community. His Stirrings have returned, and he has pleasurable dreams that make him feel a little guilty, but he refuses to give up the heightened feelings that the Stirrings and his wonderful memories have given him.
The Giver tells him that sometimes his pain makes him want to apply for a release, but he is not allowed to do it until Jonas is trained. Upon Jonas's pleading, The Giver relents and tells him the story about the failed Receiver.
In <em>The Case of the Defaced Painting</em>, we immediately encounter details that can help us solve the mystery. Part 1 of the story contains several clues. We learn that there is paint on the floor and on the chair that is close to the painting. We also learn that Mrs. Williams seems to be angry about the fact that her husband cares about the paintings so much. Finally, we also learn that Mrs. William is not wearing her wedding ring.
