Sarah is a local politician running for a seat on the city council. She is preparing a speech she will give tomorrow to a group
consisting of senior citizens and members of the PTA (Parents Teachers Association). She is hoping her speech will increase support for her campaign. Knowing what you do about the circumstances surrounding Sara’s speech, which of the following options would NOT provide Sara’s argument with validity nor remain relevant to her argument?
A.
a positive survey of senior citizens regarding their experience working with Sara
B.
a positive survey of teachers and parents regarding their experience working with Sara
C.
a positive survey of politicians regarding their experience working with Sara
D.
a positive survey of high school students regarding their experience working with Sara
D. a positive survey of high school students regarding their experience working with Sara
Explanation:
Since Sara is running for a seat on the city council and giving a speech in front of parents and teachers, it would be suitable for her to include information about how she has dealt with politicians, senior citizens, teachers and parents. Therefore, providing a survey on her past experiences with adolescents would not be appropriate to the purpose of the speech, which is to encourage adult citizens to vote for her.
