What if you go to the dollar store and look for some neat prizes. There's also lots of different type of glow sticks there. Rings, bracelets, necklaces, earrings, Disney themed ones. It depends on the games that you guys are planning on having also.
Maybe you could make the prizes. or you could go to the dollar store or if you could buy big bags of candy or donate old little knick knacks you don't want anymore. sorry if i didn't help.. but i hope it does
