The essay has to be 5 paragraphs right? And what’s it’s got be about?? is it just a persuasive essay in general or is there a topic that you have to persuade???
It depends. If the female is the best. I would use the second. If the female was, I would use the first
If this is how you've presented the question, Its a bit hard to answer it when one hasn't read these books. It'd be best if you'd put both books into a summary for us to go based off of, at most.