They are both grammatically correct it is just that the former is using perfact past. As sited from <span>Cambridge Grammar of the English Language "</span>The preterite perfect [i.e. the past perfect] locates the writing anterior to an intermediate time which is anterior to the time of speaking - it is doubly anterior (140). "
Answer:
deserted of people and in a state of bleak and dismal emptiness.
Explanation:
barren or laid waste; devastated: a treeless, desolate landscape. deprived or destitute of inhabitants; deserted; uninhabited. solitary; lonely: a desolate place. having the feeling of being abandoned by friends or by hope; forlorn.
<span>An appeal to the speaker's credibility, This is also a form of pathos B</span>
