I think that 'more genuine' would complete the sentence best.
Well for the first question i’d ask how different things were compared to now
Answer
A. Everything the fortune cookie predicted would happen to Kyle came true.
Explanation
C and D. There is no supernatural element to the story
For C they compete to create a haunted house but there’s no paranormal activity (I.e ghosts) which would suggest there’s anything supernatural.
For B the traffic lights could have been green due to probability/chance. It also doesn’t state how many intersections there were.
For A, there is some mysterious/supernatural element in the fact that a cookie was able to provide Kyle’s destiny/future.