1answer.
Ask question
Login Signup
Ask question
All categories
  • English
  • Mathematics
  • Social Studies
  • Business
  • History
  • Health
  • Geography
  • Biology
  • Physics
  • Chemistry
  • Computers and Technology
  • Arts
  • World Languages
  • Spanish
  • French
  • German
  • Advanced Placement (AP)
  • SAT
  • Medicine
  • Law
  • Engineering
Blizzard [7]
3 years ago
10

What was the main flaw in the sepreme courts reasoning in Plessy v. Ferguson

English
1 answer:
devlian [24]3 years ago
8 0
N Plessy v. Ferguson (1896), the Supreme Court considered the constitutionality of a Louisiana law passed in 1890 "providing for separate railway carriages for the white and colored races." The law, which required that all passenger railways provide separate cars for blacks and whites, stipulated that the cars be equal in facilities, banned whites from sitting in black cars and blacks in white cars (with exception to "nurses attending children of the other race"), and penalized passengers or railway employees for violating its terms. 

<span>Homer Plessy, the plaintiff in the case, was seven-eighths white and one-eighth black, and had the appearance of a white man. On June 7, 1892, he purchased a first-class ticket for a trip between New Orleans and Covington, La., and took possession of a vacant seat in a white-only car. Duly arrested and imprisoned, Plessy was brought to trial in a New Orleans court and convicted of violating the 1890 law. He then filed a petition against the judge in that trial, Hon. John H. Ferguson, at the Louisiana Supreme Court, arguing that the segregation law violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, which forbids states from denying "to any person within their jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws," as well as the Thirteenth Amendment, which banned slavery. </span>

<span>The Court ruled that, while the object of the Fourteenth Amendment was to create "absolute equality of the two races before the law," such equality extended only so far as political and civil rights (e.g., voting and serving on juries), not "social rights" (e.g., sitting in a railway car one chooses). As Justice Henry Brown's opinion put it, "if one race be inferior to the other socially, the constitution of the United States cannot put them upon the same plane." Furthermore, the Court held that the Thirteenth Amendment applied only to the imposition of slavery itself. </span>

<span>The Court expressly rejected Plessy's arguments that the law stigmatized blacks "with a badge of inferiority," pointing out that both blacks and whites were given equal facilities under the law and were equally punished for violating the law. "We consider the underlying fallacy of [Plessy's] argument" contended the Court, "to consist in the assumption that the enforced separation of the two races stamps the colored race with a badge of inferiority. If this be so, it is not by reason of anything found in the act, but solely because the colored race chooses to put that construction upon it." </span>

<span>Justice John Marshall Harlan entered a powerful -- and lone -- dissent, noting that "in view of the Constitution, in the eye of the law, there is in this country no superior, dominant, ruling class of citizens. There is no caste here. Our Constitution is color-blind, and neither knows nor tolerates classes among citizens." </span>

<span>Until the mid-twentieth century, Plessy v. Ferguson gave a "constitutional nod" to racial segregation in public places, foreclosing legal challenges against increasingly-segregated institutions throughout the South. The railcars in Plessy notwithstanding, the black facilities in these institutions were decidedly inferior to white ones, creating a kind of racial caste society. However, in the landmark decision Brown v. Board of Education (1954), the "separate but equal" doctrine was abruptly overturned when a unanimous Supreme Court ruled that segregating children by race in public schools was "inherently unequal" and violated the Fourteenth Amendment. Brown provided a major catalyst for the civil rights movement (1955-68), which won social, not just political and civil, racial equality before the law. After four decades, Justice Harlan's dissent became the law of the land. Following Brown, the Supreme Court has consistently ruled racial segregation in public settings to be unconstitutional. </span>
You might be interested in
Explain what Beowulf is preparing to do at the beginning of section XXI, and describe what values underlie his decision. Cite te
Mnenie [13.5K]
Beowulf is preparing to kill Grendel's mother and restore order by avenging Aeschere and putting an end to the blood feud. His heroic view of life is that it is better to die with the glory of avenging our friends, than to live and wait for the life to end naturally, in peace. That is a true warrior's destiny: "Each of us all must his end abidein the ways of the world; so win who mayglory ere death! When his days are told,that is the warrior’s worthiest doom."
8 0
3 years ago
How can reading out loud help you understand difficult lines in shakespear?
Fiesta28 [93]
Sometimes being able to here something aloud enables you to understand it a lot better
8 0
3 years ago
The central idea in Act V of The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet concerns the.....
AleksandrR [38]
B. dangers of disobedience.
7 0
3 years ago
It is fragment sentence.<br> looked in his eyes and knew he was “the one”.
elena-14-01-66 [18.8K]

Answer:

Yes it is?

Explanation:

I'm not sure what you are asking here but thanks for the point love ya PEACE

4 0
3 years ago
Read 2 more answers
Which source of information would offer the most reliable fact-based information about J.R.R. Tolkien, the author of The Lord of
EastWind [94]
The correct option is B.
The source of information, that would offer the most reliable fact-based information about the author is a book, that is written by the author himself. This type of source is called primary source. Information obtained from Wikipedia, movie and books published by other authors can only offer secondary information, which are not as reliable as information from primary source.
3 0
3 years ago
Read 2 more answers
Other questions:
  • Which sentence includes an infinitive used as a direct object?
    6·2 answers
  • Why may the Lady in “The Lady of Shalott” not leave her island? a. She has no means of transport at the poem’s beginning. b. A c
    8·2 answers
  • What does the roadmender tell monsieur defarge?
    8·1 answer
  • Which sentence is capitalized correctly? i visit mr. sanchez every monday at his office on north columbia drive. i visit mr. san
    14·2 answers
  • Can you think of a time when a border was helpful?
    6·1 answer
  • Which of these is correctly punctuated?
    7·2 answers
  • Which is not one of the five stages of plot?
    5·2 answers
  • A chorus has 50 singers. There are 16 altos and 10 tenors. What percent of
    8·1 answer
  • Read the passage carefully. Which sentence best incorporates a direct quote from the passage?
    8·1 answer
  • (A Raisin in the Sun)
    9·1 answer
Add answer
Login
Not registered? Fast signup
Signup
Login Signup
Ask question!