Dude, the word isn't underlined. From what I can... assume, the word that's supposed to be underlined is "riddled."
The best option is, Perforated. The comparison to a sponge makes it obvious too, because sponges have holes. Check out the definition for Perforated below.
After talking with Elizabeth in act 4, John decides to C. <span>confess because staying silent would imply that he has never lied be hanged because he deserves to die for his adultery—not for witchcraft.</span>
