Republic
old
intense
multicultural
practical
roman
isolated
vast
exhausting
rich
Everyone was subject to law
Answer:
If/when chosen by the people you get a more appealing outcome.
Because... The determining factors are YOUR family, friends, and town-folk. It's the people you grew up with. So you all are aware of the same problems in your city/state and you are more than likely both thinking of the same solution. Where as, if chosen by a legislature, you have a bunch of well paid senators who may not see all the things normal people do since they work and live indoors and nowhere near the problems most of the time. They don't care for the middle to lower classes. Most just care about the rich and how to make themselves better and wealthier. It sucks to see, and even more to be living in this kind of world but it's just how it is.
Your going to have to be much more specific. Progress in what?
Rome is in the middle of Italy. Italy is the Mediterranean country found in the southern middle part of Europe and looks like a boot.