Question

What would James Madison say about allowing a person elected to the house of representatives to srve at the same toime on the supreme cout? Exlaxain you thinking.

Answer 1

Answer:

He would not be happy due to the fact that he wanted all the 3 powers to be separated from one other. His reason for being unhappy will be because he felt the separation of the powers couldn't be possible with the system in the question stated where there is 1 representative for 2 powers.

Explanation:

He would not be happy due to the fact that he wanted all the 3 powers to be separated from one other. His reason for being unhappy will be because he felt the separation of the powers couldn't be possible with the system in the question stated where there is 1 representative for 2 powers.

The major reasoning behind his thinking is that if one person were allowed to serve in both house of reps and Supreme court, they would likely influence the others in both branches to take side with them which could lead to forming a strong force with two of the branches, which will in turn lead to a great threat to the system.