This seminal poem was both a revelation and incendiary at the time it was written by Kishwar Naheed. It is a declaration of the
independence of women who did not subscribe to societal and cultural norms. These norms imposed on women are oppressive and confining, and for the most part still exist today in Pakistan. Discuss the above statement in the light of the current situation in the Pakistani society. Justify your response by quoting examples from the poem as a reference. (5) What characteristics of contemporary literature is highlighted in the poem "We Sinful women" written by Kishwar Naheed. (5)
Pakistan today has severely repressed and punished women. This is because the country was dominated by the Taliban, which imposes a very sexist and oppressive position in society, in relation to women. In this way, women are diminished, forbidden to study, work, sexually repressed and punished for any behavior considered incorrect by the Taliban. Within this context, Kishwar Naheed's poem highlights how women have been judged as sinners, for behaviors that protect them from this type of reality. The poem reinforces the idea that even with this oppression and judgment women are strong and it is this strength that many try to hold back.
This poem addresses a current social issue, addressing a minority that is marginalized indiscriminately and without just reasons, which is common in contemporary literature.
The First Amendment of the United States Constitution protects the right to freedom of religion and freedom of expression from government interference, not us.
