And, what is the question you are asking? I don't really understand..
Based on the definition of appositive, this is a noun or noun phrase that is used to rename the another noun beside it. Basing on the given sentence above, I believe that it does not have an appositive. The nouns are Joe and Tulips, but no other noun that renames either of the two.
Hope this helps bro.
Answer:
A- Because he is a proven crook, my opponent's points are invalid.
Explanation:
>Ad hominem fallacy is creating a reason for something without logic
Answer:
wdym? i can if you tell me-
Explanation:
