1. one of the men is the commander the other is the stranger 2. I think it is so that way there is a slight origin to where the story came from. 3. I think Rip's long sleep is a punishment cause the world has changed and twenty or so years have passed. 4. Rip has a "meekness of spirit" this is blamed from the nagging of his wife. 5. One other character I can think of that sorta compares to Rip van Winkle is Ichabod Crane 6. I think Rip is consistent with his actions 7. The Inn, The flagon drink, and The union hotel 8. 9. It's probably not to realistic sense the author has never really been to it 10. So that way he would wake up at the perfect time of the civil war.
