Question

Fred Sweet runs dancing classes for middle-aged and elderly people. Some of Fred's customers lack physical coordination, and injuries from kicks, falls, etc. are common. Fred naturally fears that injured customers will sue him for negligence. Thus, he makes each customer sign a written contract containing a clause relieving Fred of all liability for injuries suffered during his dancing classes. However, fearful that he will lose business if potential customers become aware of his strategy, Fred states the clause in fine print and doesn't point it out to them. An injured customer sues Fred in negligence. Fred wants to defend on the basis of the clause in the contract. Which of the following is the biggest weakness in Fred's position? A. That Fred tried to use an exculpatory clause at all, because such clauses are invalid on public policy grounds. B. That Fred tried to use an exculpatory clause to relieve himself of negligence liability. C. That Fred has superior bargaining power, which makes the customer's acceptance of the exculpatory clause involuntary. D. That Fred used a fine-print exculpatory clause, which means that the customer lacked knowledge of the clause's existence

Answer 1

Answer: the correct answer is D. That Fred used a fine-print exculpatory clause, which means that the customer lacked knowledge of the clause's existence.