Question

Explain in a few sentences whether this document could be used to support Engels’s claims about the working class in England. Document: A diary entry from 1844, written by a worker living in Manchester. It describes crowded and filthy conditions in that city.

Answer 1

Answer:

yes, it could be used.

Explanation:

Engels work, relating to unfavorable working conditions, relates directly to the time and place of the diary´s entry, and for that reason, it could be used as a firsthand personal illustration of Engel´s thesis. Nevertheless, it should be treated as merely one example, one single viewpoint, upon a problem whose context and dimensions are far greater than one man´s perspective; that is to say, the entry diary can work as one historical source amongst the many more that a reliable argument should employ in trying to support and fundament Engel´s thesis.

Answer 2

Answer:

Yes

Explanation:

This document would be a perfect source to support Engels's claims about the working class in England. Engels argued that the working class all over the world was being exploited. They worked long hours for very little pay. Moreover, they lived and worked in crowded and filthy conditions. The only people who profited from this arrangement were the business owners and producers that hired these people. Therefore, the diary would accurately describe the problems that Engels outlined.