Question

The society in the house of the scorpion apparently believes that raising clones specifically for the purpose of harvesting their organs is morally acceptable because their brains have been destroyed, so they don't suffer. Do you think this argument is rational. Explain.

Answer 1

I do not think it is a totally invalid argument, since the brain that gives us the sensation and pain, or better, it transmits the sensation of pain to us through the neurons, but in a way it is a doubtful point and a difficult argument.

But rationally speaking if the pain doesn't exist then the possibility is valid in that sense.