It’s either C or D, but i’m pretty sure it’s C
I believe the answer is A, I could be wrong though :)
3/4 of the bat blood was used = 18/24 most Ethel
2/3 of the knotgrass was used= 16/24 more Locasta
1/2 of the moonstone was used=12/24 less Circe
3/8 of the unicorn hair was used=9/24 least Glinda
Circe used the moonstone