Question

Read this claim and counterclaim. Claim: Cities should ban the sale of soda in cups larger than sixteen ounces. Counterclaim: Cities should not limit the size of soda cups. Which evidence best addresses the counterclaim?

Answer 1

Answer:

A fact about how many calories a sixteen-ounce cup of soda contains.

Explanation:

According to a different source, these are the options that come with this question:

• A story about a girl who drinks two sixteen-ounce cups of soda at lunch.
• An article about how soda was invented.
• A quotation from a parent whose child does not like soda.
• A fact about how many calories a sixteen-ounce cup of soda contains.

In this example, the author first proposes banning soda in cups larger than sixteen ounces. However, people who oppose this argue that cities should not have this power. In order to address the counterclaim effectively, we need to provide evidence of why it is actually a good idea to ban soda in such cups. A way to show the reasoning behind this action is by sharing a fact about how many calories a sixteen-ounce cup of soda contains.