In The Scarlet Letter, Hester finds herself in the midst of a whirlwind of accusation and ostracism, even though she knows she i
s not the only imperfect person in the colony. She wears her red letter A, knowing it marks her apart from everyone else, but also knowing that the letter “has not done its office.” The townspeople hoped that the letter would make her consider her relationship with God, but Hester feels this is a private matter. When the townspeople begin to feel Hester’s letter has changed meanings because of Hester’s good deeds and helping the poor, they consider the idea of letting Hester take off the letter. For this discussion, consider the following questions:
Would the removal of the scarlet letter be as pointless as forcing Hester to wear it in the first place? Be sure to give textual support in your answer.
Has there been a time when you were ostracized because of a single act? Did you act like Hester, enforcing the distinction between you and the group, or did you seek forgiveness for your action?
Is it better to be true to yourself and be separate or to seek forgiveness for a perceived wrong?
Write a short summary of your answers to the questions.
