Question

Fossils of ancestors of the modern horses show a small, 4-toed, almost dog-like browsing animal named Eohippus. Over time, the horses got larger, lost toes, and changed to a grazing diet. What is the best explanation for why this change occurred?

Answer 1

The best answer would be it has happened because of natural selection.
Over many generations, natural selection  selects the traits that bring advantages to it's holders. In the case of the horse ancestors, the traits selected were all adaptation to living in the steppe, the vast grasslands.
Over time, the individuals who could run the fastest and avoid the predators and utilize the resource that is most available in the grasslands- grass would be the most successful, leave more offspring and eventually be more prevalent in the population.