Wow that's a hard one. Ummm....
For the 8 inch pie you are paying about 55 cents per inch
for the 10 inch pie you are paying about 61 cents per inch
so the 8 inch pie is a better deal
hope this helped
oh and to get those numbers divide 4.39 by 8 and 6.15 by 10
Add 2.38 and 4.89 then subtract 3 giving you 4.27