Logically that’s the only viable choice, he clearly isn’t handsome, he does appreciate the landlord’s daughter, and he never shared any traits that would make him “a good robber”.
I cannot see the whole thing, but I have read this story and LOVED it!! I will try to help.
Answer:
D. The man they are describing, is clearly a very unattractive man. Therefore he would not be A. So it is either D, or B. If you could update the picture I would be able to answer better. I hope this helps!!!!