1answer.
Ask question
Login Signup
Ask question
All categories
  • English
  • Mathematics
  • Social Studies
  • Business
  • History
  • Health
  • Geography
  • Biology
  • Physics
  • Chemistry
  • Computers and Technology
  • Arts
  • World Languages
  • Spanish
  • French
  • German
  • Advanced Placement (AP)
  • SAT
  • Medicine
  • Law
  • Engineering
zhannawk [14.2K]
3 years ago
10

Write about the Pros of Indian Judiciary system (for a debate)? (urgent pls)

Social Studies
2 answers:
stich3 [128]3 years ago
8 0

answer:

answer:

explanation:

explanation:

BartSMP [9]3 years ago
7 0

Answer:

The collegium system must not see itself as being above the safeguards and measures for transparency, accountability and demographic representation that apply to India’s pillars of democracy.

In September 2019, Chief Justice of Madras High Court Vijaya Kamlesh Tahilramani resigned after the collegium upheld their decision to transfer her to the high court of Meghalaya (one of the smallest in the country). Justice Tahilramani was the senior-most high-court judge in the country. The members of the bar associations across Tamil Nadu protested against this move and carried “a one-day court boycott.” In addition, in Maharashtra's Latur, about 2,000 lawyers boycotted court proceedings to protest the transfer. The collegium responded by saying that they have “cogent reasons” for the transfer, and will reveal them if required.

At the heart of this controversy is the functioning of the collegium system, which makes decisions about appointments and transfers in the higher judiciary. In February 2020, former Supreme Court judge and member of the collegium from 2018–2019, Arjan Kumar Sikri, said that far from a “scientific study” about candidates, “most times, we [the collegium] go by “our impression” when appointing judges [to high courts and the Supreme Court].”

The collegium system is headed by the Chief Justice of India (CJI) and four senior-most judges of the Supreme Court. India’s Constitution originally stipulated that the judges of the Supreme Court and high courts would be appointed by the President based on a process of “consultation” with senior judges. The present collegium system emerged later based on three key rulings. In 1981, the “First Judges Case” ruled that the process of consultation with the CJI and other judges did not require a consensus about recommendations. Essentially, the ruling gave the central government “primacy in judicial appointments.” In 1993, the “Second Judges Case” overturned this decision and introduced the collegium system, arguing that “consultation” required “concurrence.” Specifically, the ruling said that the process of appointing judges would be based on “an institutional opinion formed in consultation with the two senior-most judges in the Supreme Court” and the CJI. In 1998, the “Third Judges Case” ruled that the collegium would be a five-member body, establishing the system that is most similar to the one currently being followed.

This reading list details how the current system can be reformed.

Opaque and Unaccountable System

C Raj Kumar writes that the lack of information about the appointment of judges, including the criteria based on which the judges make their choice, is “the most persuasive criticism of the collegium system.”

   Without a transparent process of the appointment of judges, the collegium system will not have the credibility and the legitimacy for it to be accepted by all stakeholders within the legal system. Transparency will not be established merely by stating that the members of the collegium will act in a transparent manner. It will have to be demonstrated by the process that the judiciary adopts in the selection of judges.

The lack of transparency and the absence of formal criteria have multiple worrying implications. Presently, there is no structured process to investigate if a judge who is recommended by the collegium has any conflict of interests. This is important in the context where the

   … collegium has been fraught with serious allegations of different types of alleged conflict of interest among the members of the collegium and the individuals they have selected to become judges of the High Courts and the Supreme Court. There is an urgent need for the collegium to formulate a detailed set of rules and regulations that will govern the determination of conflict of interest among the members of the collegium who are involved in the selection of judges.

Social Background of Judges  

Alok Prasanna Kumar identifies that the collegium system prefers practising lawyers rather than appointing and promoting “judges of the subordinate judiciary,” which often comprises a diverse pool of candidates.

You might be interested in
How do deontological or kantian theories of right and wrong differ from consequentialism?
Finger [1]

Answer:

The answer is explained below

Explanation:

Deontological and Consequentialism are two theories in ethics. Consequentialism is more focused on judging the moral worth of out actions while deontological ethics focus on judging the action.  Consequences focuses on consequences. The utilitarian theory of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill is an example of consequentialism. Immanual Kant was the first philosopher to define deontological principles.

7 0
3 years ago
Which of the following biomes are considered temperate biomes
Gelneren [198K]
The right answer for the question that is being asked and shown above is that: "c. rainforest and tundra." the biomes that are considered temperate biomes are the c. rainforest and tundra

These are the following choices:
a. deciduous forests and grasslands
b. chaparral and tundra
c. rainforest and tundra
d. alpine and deciduous forests
5 0
3 years ago
Read 2 more answers
According to the Austrian business cycle theory which of the following is true about the economy?
valentinak56 [21]

Answer:

D) All of the above

Explanation:

This theory was created by the Austrian School in order to explain and understand the market growth based on the credit increase proposed by bank institutions (a central bank). In other words, this theory arguments that the economic cycles, especially financial crisis and recession, are caused by the "creation" of the money. How this money will be used and the result of this application is the central concern of this theory.

4 0
3 years ago
Revised path-goal theory indicates to managers that they must consider
Ilia_Sergeevich [38]

Answer:

B.) modifying their leadership style to fit employee and task characteristics.

Explanation:

Revised path-goal theory refers to the leadership theory in which a leader's support is crucial for the followers to achieve their goals. The theory is based on the leader's behavior that fits the employee's needs and environment for the accomplishment of their goals. According to the theory, leaders work to encourage employees and remove their roadblocks so that they can perform well.

3 0
3 years ago
What is the significance of the quotation, "'You want to help me change my life?" Mom asked. "I'm fine. You're the one who needs
Karo-lina-s [1.5K]

Answer:

This quotation shows the different view point between Jeannette's and her mother on materialism, from the book, The Glass Castle

 

Explanation:

From the quotation we can safely say that Jeannette's mother is not materialistic in nature, hence she makes Jeannette understand that she do not need money for true happiness.

6 0
3 years ago
Other questions:
  • Aristotle believed that human beings are not separate from nature, but are part of nature.
    7·1 answer
  • How do demand curves move when there is an increase or a decrease in demand?
    9·2 answers
  • Hitting your head at 15 mph __________ A. has the same force of impact as being hit with a sledgehammer. B. will rarely cause in
    15·2 answers
  • Pleaseeee, help me.
    10·1 answer
  • Which statement was true of the muckrakers?
    7·1 answer
  • Can someone help please?<br> Explain how the merit system benefited Chinese society.
    9·1 answer
  • What can be your contribution to end the gender discrimination in our<br>society​
    14·1 answer
  • How should Civil rights. be used ?write an example. pls help me. ​
    10·1 answer
  • Emancipation Proclamation freed ALL the slaves <br><br> A. True <br> B. False
    5·1 answer
  • List the counties named after the 8 Lords Proprietors
    7·1 answer
Add answer
Login
Not registered? Fast signup
Signup
Login Signup
Ask question!