Yes they can! Just because two plots have the same IQR and range, does not mean that the rest of the data has to be the exact same. For example, the median.
750 dollars in total <=500+250=750
250/750=1/3 or 33.33333333%
When you cannot simplify it further. The terms have no common factor besides 1 and A plus C does not have two numbers that multiply to the total and equal C.