Observe that
Now,
so that
To decide which is the correct value, we need to examine the sign of . It evaluates to 0 if
We have
Also,
and increases as increases, which means
Therefore for all ,
For example, when , we get
Then the target expression has a negative sign at the given value of :
Alternatively, we can try simplifying by denesting the radical. Let be non-zero integers () such that
Note that the left side must be positive.
Taking squares on both sides gives
Let and . Then
Only the first case leads to integer coefficients. Since , one of or must be negative. We have
Now if , then , and
However, , so is negative, so we don't want this.
Instead, if , then , and thus
Then our target expression evaluates to