One wouldn’t allow for passive transport. And the other would allow to much. The membrane serves as a gate. Non-permeable would be a solid wall were nothing and no one can get through or get out . Including things like water. And fully permeable would represent no gate at all and would allow to much in and out of the cell.
Anything that relates to sexual reproduction (gametes coming together to fertilize) should be crossed off.
Not much context was provided but you can look back to some other questions I've answered, I have a full in-depth answer to the same question another person had.
