Answer: Both of their statements are true. Explanation: If you can buy 5 shirts for $20, that means the unit price would be $4 per shirt. (to find the unit price just divide the cost by the quantity) So, it is true that you can buy one shirt for $4 and 2 shirts for $8. Hopefully this helps.
I know yours is an equation which is why I did not go any further because this is the standard form you are looking for. I would rewrite mine to get my hyperbola standard form. However the one I have provided is the form you need where mine would be.