Answer:
No I don't agree with their solution; both their answers are wrong.
Correct answer is
.
Step-by-step explanation:
Given:

Now given:
According to Mai
and According to Tyler 
Now we need to find which of them is correct.
So we will solve the given equation we get;

Subtracting both side by 1 we get;

Now Multiplying both side
we get;

Hence both of them are incorrect, correct answer is
.